Projo 7 to 7 News Blog

Taking the news pulse of Rhode Island and Southeastern Massachusetts, by Providence Journal and projo.com staff, from 7 to 7, every business day

Get the 7 to 7 on your mobile at www.projo.com. Twitter: projo | RSS | Email alerts

Update: Questioning of heart doc gets testy at Woods trial

5:33 PM Mon, Nov 30, 2009 |
Maria Armental    Email

By John Hill
Journal Staff Writer

WARWICK, R.I. -- A cardiac specialist called to testify by Kent Hospital in a negligence lawsuit told a jury Monday morning that Dr. Kelli Naylor "practiced well above the standard of care for this gentleman" while she was treating Michael J. Woods for what became a fatal heart attack in the hospital's emergency room on July 26, 2006.

Kent Hospital and Naylor are being sued by the Woods family for negligence in Woods' death. Woods, the brother of actor James Woods, had owned a Warwick video store and run twice for mayor.

Cardiologist Bruce D. Hettleman testified that Woods' symptoms were not specific to a heart attack and could have been caused by other life-threatening problems.

Even if Naylor had begun to treat Woods for the clogged arteries or blood clot that killed him later that day, Hettleman said, scar tissue and work to repair Woods' artery in 2006 would have severely complicated any effort to treat him.

"I think it would have been a very hard time," Hettleman said under direct examination by hospital lawyer David W. Carroll.

The afternoon cross examination by Mark B. Decof, the lawyer representing the Woods' estate, got testy at times.

Decof began his questioning by noting Hettleman had used the term "widow maker" 20 times to describe Michael Woods' condition, a blocked coronary artery with a blot clot.
He pressed Hettleman as to whether he meant to say anyone with such a condition "is doomed to die no matter what."

"You're correct," Hettleman said. "Not everyone dies."

Decof repeatedly asked Hettleman if he felt a cardiac condition should have been dealt with more promptly than Naylor did that day. Hettleman said Woods' symptoms -- swollen glands with a sore throat and vomiting that came on suddenly -- were so non-specific that it she could not have been expected to conclude it was cardiac related.

Decof pointed to an electrocardiogram of Woods' heartbeat that was taken about 80 minutes before he was stricken and asked whether it merited swift action to prevent a heart attack. Hettleman testified it was abnormal but not enough to justify Naylor abandoning other possible diagnoses.

Hettleman often used Decof's questions to repeat the steps Naylor took and repeat his endorsement of her actions. That led Decof, on more than one occasion, to tell Hettleman he hadn't answered the question.

More than once, Associate Justice Daniel A. Procaccini stepped in, once telling Hettleman that Decof had asked a "simple, direct question" and for him to answer "yes or no." Procaccini later cautioned Hettleman about adding "gratuitous" comments in his answers.

"We're not here to have an argument," Procaccini said. "Mr. Decof is asking very simple appropriate questions. He's doing his job."

The trial is expected to resume Tuesday morning.

social bookmarking

Comments

Dan said:

The fact remains that Dr. Naylor had ordered monitoring and that Kent County Hospital FAILED to implement that treatment as ordered by the physician. Whoever gets the final blame; the physician who did not follow up, the nurse who put Mr. Woods in the hallway, the "flight-controller" charge nurse who had no clue as to what was transpiring, or some combo, the fact remains he was not handled properly. He was allowed to crash and burn before anyone did anything. Kent needs to get their act together and fess up to this screw up. How many "near-miss" situations do we not know about?



Courtney said:

Haha the above comment is clearly not from anyone who knows anything about a cardiac monitor. It wouldn't have made a difference. It would have maybe bought him 10-15 extra seconds of CPR. Cardiac monitors are almost useless these days. They do not warn you of impending doom! This man slumped over and CPR was started almost immediately, I am sure that his monitor wouldn't have shown anything until he slumped over.

Furthermore, he wasn't on a monitor because there were no more monitored beds available (I don't know all the facts, but that is what it looks like to me). What were they supposed to do, take another patient off a monitor? The charge nurse, who put the patient in the hallway, is not responsible for knowing everything about a patient. That nurse is responsible for making sure the ER runs as smoothly as possible. The nurse taking care of the patient is the one who is supposed to know if they are on a monitor. It is possible that she didn't know, which is probably because her seven!!! ER patients all have two pages of orders written in terrible handwriting that she was deciphering, haha.



JLET said:

Thanks for the medical opinion Cournety. Sounds like you must be in the nuress union. Cardiac montitoring would in fact identify, if present, a malignant arrythmia, precursosrs to a malignant arrythmia, and depending on the type of monitor, ST-T waves changes (changes in specific components of the ECG) suggesting an evolving myocardial infaction ("heart attack"). Then again, we will never know what it may have shown as he was never placed on a cardiac monitor. If there were no more monitors, how was it he was placed on one when he suffered a cardiac arrest ?



anne smith said:

when a hospital has no beds it should reroute pts,a hosp that continues to take pts into the er knowing they have no beds and are understaffed is wrong.a sneek peek to managed care!



Dan said:

Courtney:

Unfortunately, I do. Had he been placed on a monitor and the monitor watched by the nurse (he was ordered on a monitor for irregular heartbeat per the testimony) there in all probability would have been changes to kick up his treatment. If Kent couldn't follow the physicians orders and he needed to be monitored he should have been transferred. He would have received better treatment in any ALS resuce in the state than he received at Kent! You refer to the staffing levels which is all too true, but no excuse since she is supposed to triage the level of care necessary. Hopefully, electronic record keeping will help the handwriting issues. I've seen it in use, and once trained, the physicians, nurses, pharmacists, and billing depts. all love it. I just wonder how secure it is.



Barbara said:

I have been in the Kent County ER when the staff has had their hands full with patients lined up everywhere including the hallways. They (the staff members) also wish that many of those patients had been sent to other hospitals so that they could get more of the attention they need. There isn't much they can do if the ambulances and rescues are dumping patients left and right on top of the people walking in off the street and there are only so many of them to handle it all. Maybe they could have taken him to Rhode Island Hosp. where they never make mistakes, like operating on or removing wrong body parts, etc. Unfortunately all hospitals have their problems and they all bury their mistakes, always been that way and always will be.



hulaHANAWINKLE said:

If he had been put on a cardiac monitor, the doctor probably would have ordered a cardiac drip which would have killed him since they knew so little about him. Pick your poison.



Catherine said:

Everyone is giving their testimony---that is what a trial is for. In this case Michael Woods was not given the proper care. This seems quite obvious. Whatever the chances were he deserved that chance. He was not given that chance. I had a simular experience at Kent and I was transported Miriam. I realize now how lucky I was. Mine was also heart related.



Elizabeth said:

If you have a cardiac event, GO TO MIRIAM HOSPITAL. This place is the gold standard for cardiac care in RI, and their ER is well run and staffed.

I feel like wearing a bracelet that says "Take me to Miriam Hospital in case of heart attack" so no EMT dumps me at Kent or RIH. It's too bad Michael Woods didn't know this.



my 2cents said:

It's too bad michael woods didn't understand smoking drinking and obesity all contribute to heart attacks.

And it is likely that if he was going to have an event he wouldn't died enroute.

Should we sue the people who drove him to Kent instead of RIH or Miriam. Surely we could get some money from them because they should have known better.



jlet said:

my 2cents, he drove himself...



Ted said:

Hi,
I am very interested in knowing more facts about this case. I see in your comments that some of you talk with confidence that knowing of facts and data usually gives you. Is it any place where I can see the whole history of this case, such as timing of various events, diagnoses, labs, etc..

Thanks




Leave a comment

Please be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published. Name and email are required; email address will not publish.




Type the characters you see in the picture above.