Projo 7 to 7 News Blog

Taking the news pulse of Rhode Island and Southeastern Massachusetts, by Providence Journal and projo.com staff, from 7 to 7, every business day

Get the 7 to 7 on your mobile at www.projo.com. Twitter: projo | RSS | Email alerts

Carcieri urges Assembly to outlaw indoor prostitution

4:39 PM Thu, Jun 18, 2009 |
Lynn Arditi    Email

PROVIDENCE, R.I. -- Governor Donald L. Carcieri joined representatives of the state's top law enforcement agencies Thursday afternoon to urge lawmakers to make indoor prostitution in Rhode Island a crime.

At a State House news conference, the governor urged state lawmakers to pass one or both bills pending in the General Assembly that would close a "loophole" in the state prostitution law that he said "has allowed indoor prostitution to flourish.''

Two bills to outlaw indoor prostitution are pending in the General Assembly. One, introduced by (introduced by Sen. Paul V. Jabour, D-Providence, is scheduled for a hearing at about 4:30 p.m. Thursday in the Senate Judiciary Committee. The bill needs to pass both the full House and Senate in order to become law.

The governor said he had invited Jabour to the news conference but that the senator was unable to attend. Jabour, a lawyer, said later that he was at a mandatory seminar at the Rhode Island Bar Association.

He said his bill includes a section holding landlords accountable, something he felt was important despite strong opposition from property owners.

"I know there's a strong undertow against this bill from the property owners," Jabour said. "They're the silent force against this -- big hotels, big property owners."

"In some way, we've got to smoke out the skunks and see who's against it," he said.

In the House, a bill introduced by Rep.Joanne M. Giannini, D-Providence, in May passed the House by a vote of 62 to 8. It has yet to be scheduled for a hearing in the Senate.


Jabour's bill, which was introduced as a companion bill to Giannini's, lacks several changes that were made to Giannini's bill during the hearing process.

For example, it does not have a clause that provides immunity from prosecution for victims of sex-trafficking.

Jabour's bill includes a section -- removed from Giannini's bill, on the advice of legal counsel -- that would allow prosecution of landlords who permit prostitution on their properties. For a first offense, a landlord could face up to six months in jail and fines of up to $1,000.

Governor Carcieri was joined by representatives of Attorney General Patrick Lynch, the state police, the Rhode Island Police Chief's Association, human rights advocates and University of Rhode Island Professor Donna M. Hughes, who has done extensive research on sex trafficking.

Stacey Pires Veroni, criminal division chief in the attorney general's office, said the current state law allows "lucrative sex businesses from out of state" to set up shop in Rhode Island, said She also said after the news conference that "We'd be kidding ourselves if we think that some of the strip clubs (in the state) are just strip clubs."

The governor also urged state lawmakers to enact a bill to strengthen the state law against sex-trafficking, particularly as it affects minors.

social bookmarking

Comments

Shhhhh said:

This is supposed to die in secret and have everyone just assume it passed. Surely the GA needs more time to "study" the issue, interview prostitutes one on one. They are willing to work nights and weekends on the matter



Joe said:

Well if this bill gets passed shall I and many other husbands turn ourselves in? We all pay for sex with our wives / girlfriends. Why else would I take either of them out to dinner?



Andrew Therrien said:

This is a must pass bill. Even though I am a libertarian 1) For public saftey this must pass and 2) and most importantly, the libertarian in me says the majority of these women in RI that are in these sex shops/brothels are being held against their will or were minipulated into coming here and are being held against their will. If we can crack down on these establishments we will bring our city to a higher level and even though we will not stop this human traffic, we can reduce its impact on RI.



Can't Legislate Morality said:

This is absurd - the solution should at least address the real issue - the male need for indiscriminate sex - not the fact that they are willing to pay for it (indoors or out)!



Rick James said:

I feel this is appalling and totally irresponsible of the governor. With the current economy and unemployment situation to intentionally put these prostitutes out of work is irresponsible and immoral. Just think of the spike in the unemployment rate and claims this will put on our already fiscally drowning state.



Guy said:

They can pass whatever laws they like but it's not going to stop prostitution. Unfortunately Amsterdam is proving that prostitution is difficult to regulate. They still have a huge trafficking problem with foreign girls and pimps. Residency papers can be forged. So we can't just make prostitution legal for citizens only, it won't solve the problem. Perhaps making pimps illegal is the way to go. Whatever our government does, it should not turn prostitutes into victims. We need to end poverty, not increase it.



Scott said:

As a former cop in providence I have disagree with the Governor and these top officials.
Prostitution will always exist does anyone doubt that? Leave it indoors or deal with in the street in front of your homes. maybe not in front of your home but in front of those good people who live on Elmwood Ave, Dexter St, Valley St, Harvard ave, Dartmouth and Douglas ave. to name a few. You'll never stop prostitution NEVER all you can do is try and control it, that's it. Let them stay inside to some extent controls it. At least for the people who deal with these people on a daily basis. Supply and demand folks, as long as we're willing to pay it will never go away. Deal with it



Leave these women alone. How is arresting women helping anyone. Women who work at the spa testified at the hearing and said they are supporting families, so why put them in prison.

http://www.happyendingsdoc.com



linus said:

Is anyone thinking about how much this unnecessary legislation will cost Little Rowdy?

·Total expenditures for the ACI in 2003: $142,761,446

·How much does it cost to incarcerate? (Based on RIDOC 2003 figures)

o $27,586 for 1 year per offender-Minimum Security

o$41,742 for 1 year per offender-Maximum security

o $83,553 for 1 year per offender in High Security

In fiscal year, 2003, TAX & SPEND LITTLE RHODY managed to spend an estimated $39,922,762. incarcerating individuals convicted of non-violent offenses additional unfathomable millions of dollars in law enforcement and prosecution costs prior to incarceration.

What does our governor say about this?

Governor Carcieri's Message to the Legislature on his 2004 budget:

"The growth in costs for the Department of Corrections is one of the forces which require other state government expenditures to be constrained or reduced."

In other words…instead of capitalizing upon this “accidental” growth industry (indoor prostitution) as an economic development with accruing tax, licensing, and regulatory benefits to the State of RI, our governor is looking toward taking away “poor” families health care, care for “poor” pregnant women, prescriptions for “poor” elderly and increasing all of our taxed by reducing state aid to cities and towns.

Just glad this is his last term.


http://www.riflc.org/index.php?name=crimeincri



sue said:

When the G.A. sees a hot button issue that they must respond to,(but could care less about),they have one or more of their members submit a bill, with just the tiniest flaw in it,thus dooming it.
In this case,the flaw is: holding the landlords responsible.
Does anyone doubt this ?



CJ said:

Sure, let's bring it out on the streets where it belongs! This governor is really getting on my last nerve! With his 700 club appearance(gays/lesbians shouldn't marry), wanting patients to get their LEGAL pot on the streets rather than a safe place to purchase and now he wants prostitutes all over the corners. You are a real gem governer, a real gem. When can we vote this guy out?




Leave a comment

Please be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published. Name and email are required; email address will not publish.




Type the characters you see in the picture above.