Projo 7 to 7 News Blog

Taking the news pulse of Rhode Island and Southeastern Massachusetts, by Providence Journal and projo.com staff, from 7 to 7, every business day

Get the 7 to 7 on your mobile at www.projo.com. Twitter: projo | RSS | Email alerts

Twin River takeover talks shift to legislative arena

7:05 AM Wed, Apr 29, 2009 |
Katherine Gregg    Email


PROVIDENCE -- While Governor Carcieri appears to have closed his door, House Speaker William J. Murphy has left his door open to talks about a potential state takeover of the Twin River greyhound track and slot parlor "if the number was right.''

The sprawling Lincoln gambling hall, with 4,752 video slots, is owned by a subsidiary of BLB Investors, a holding company composed of Kerzner International, Starwood Capital Group and Waterford Group LLC. The company bought the Lincoln Park dog track in 2005, along with three greyhound racetracks and a horse track in Colorado, and then embarked on an ambitious $225-million renovation and expansion.

Since March 2008, however, when they first defaulted on their loan payments, the owners have been struggling to keep their lenders and contractors at bay without sliding or being forced into bankruptcy court.

In an interview on Tuesday, Democrat Murphy, D-West Warwick, said he did not necessarily agree with Republican Carcieri's statement that it would not be prudent, given the state's current financial situation, to "add hundreds of millions of dollars of debt to the state's balance sheet.''

With the state expecting $246.8 million in video-slot revenue from Twin River this year alone, Murphy said: "My concern is that the fiscal health of the state is protected, no matter what happens at BLB. I don't think a bankruptcy is the best scenario. I hope BLB is not forced into bankruptcy.''

So, "if the number was right,'' he said of a state buyout, "we would have to take a look at it and do a cost-benefit analysis.'' If asked, he said the legislature would also consider lifting the legislative prohibition on construction of a hotel and other resort-style amenities at the track, which in 2005 were viewed as a potential threat to the Providence hotel market.

"As of today's date,'' he said, "it is not something that we have on our horizon... here in the House of Representatives, but if times change and we are forced to act quickly -- and it's a prudent move -- I think the House of Representatives would be willing to have hearings to see what's in the best interest of the state.''

He similarly would not rule out action on state Rep. William San Bento's call for a public referendum to allow full-scale casino gambling at both Twin River and Newport Grand, saying he had not talked to the Pawtucket lawmaker -- who chairs the legislature's Lottery oversight commission -- about his proposal, "but again we have to keep all options open.''

While Murphy's statements on Tuesday were consistent with his earlier comments, they underscored the extent to which the lobbying action -- and decision-making -- had moved to the legislative arena since Twin River's announcement on Monday that the Carcieri administration had broken off talks.

On Monday, Twin River spokeswoman Patti Doyle said: "We have been informed that the governor's office has broken off all discussions with the owners of Twin River -- BLB Investors, LLC. -- regarding the possible state takeover or purchase of the gaming venue. In light of this new development, BLB will review its remaining options."

On Tuesday, Senate Majority Leader Daniel Connors echoed the governor's concern about spending hundreds of millions of dollars at this time to buy a gambling facility, saying that "certainly does seem like an awful lot of money, especially given the state's financial picture.''

But despite the apparent breakdown in talks last week, Connors said believes there is still a possible role for the state and the legislature. "I don't think the governor said or had any one of his agents say, 'you know, we don't want to hear from you anymore. We don't want to talk.' I don't think that was the message that was sent.''

Murphy has said there is only one option he would not consider: a cut in the state's share of the revenue, which currently stands at close to 60 cents out of every dollar left behind by losing players in the machines placed at Twin River by the state Lottery.

But a concerned George Nee, secretary-treasurer of the AFL-CIO, nonetheless raised that possibility, saying in an interview on Tuesday that the state should consider reducing its share of the take if that will save "about 500 union jobs up there'' and help head off a potential bankruptcy filing which, he argued, would cost the state money in any event.

"I don't think it's a good strategy to wait and see what happens,'' he said. "I think it is something that should be pursued...[and] yes, we have communicated that to the leadership, and let them know we are obviously concerned about the situation.''

Meanwhile, Gary Sasse, who has been doubling as director of both the Department of Revenue and Department of Administration, shed some light on what was considered during the months of closed-door talks.

He acknowledged, for example, that there was consideration of a state takeover with the state hiring a management company to run the slot parlor.

He said: "We explored every option. One of the options we looked at was a consensual agreement between BLB and the state where the state would take over... and the position we are in today is that we think that given the current fiscal situation, given the economy, that it would not be prudent at this point to proceed.''

He would not disclose the potential terms under discussion, but he said the administration was aware that if it decided to hire a management company to run Twin River, it would have to decide at some point "whether it would be appropriate to do it sole source or through competitive bidding. I am just saying that is an obvious question we had to ask ourselves... [but] I am not prepared to say what the result was of that conversation because the situation could still be fluid.''

On that note, Harrah's Entertainment -- having lost its West Warwick casino bid in a 2006 public referendum -- has signaled its interest in taking over the management of Twin River, should that opportunity open.

"We'd certainly be interested if that became available,'' said Jan Jones, the former Las Vegas mayor who at one point was the face of Harrah's in Rhode Island, by telephone on Monday. "We've always been big believers in the long-term benefits of being in the Rhode Island market.''

social bookmarking

Comments

Govtstench said:

We move from door number 1 to door number 2. So much for what the Governor has to say. Because BLB Investors got in trouble with their financing of this palace, now they have their hat in hand, trying to get the taxpayers to 'bail" them out. Would the legislative leaders be willing to bail every other business out that has fallen on tough times? I doubt it. Legislative leaders are listening to them because of the gambling money they get from that slot parlor. If we had an economy in this state, we would not be vulnerable to these guys.
The state should not go into the gambling business in the first place. Government mismanages everything it touchs. This will turn into a "money pit" real quick, pushing an already debt ridden budget further into the red. The Governor was correct in closing the door on this. With a $1.2 Billion in sustained red ink, we are hardly in a position to extend assistance. Perhaps Murphy, Fox, and Mr. Venda Ravioli have the bucks to bail these birds out. RI doesn't.



Carol said:

No, no, no. No bailout by the state goverment. All along the citizens of RI have voted against gambling establishments. The fact that these legislators want to "save" this establishment is a criminal act. It will only bury us further in debt. The very people who gamble cannot afford to gamble any more, which is why our "take" of the profits has dropped. As for saving 500 union jobs, what about the other thousands of residents who have lost their jobs, etc.? Stop the union scare tactics. I wish there were some way to keep a log of all these stupid decisions so we could distribut them on election day. Then, maybe some people would wake up and stop re-electing the same old boys.



Me said:

With the prices they charge at Venda he should have the money.



Kemoosabe said:

If Rhode Island bails out Twin River, who is going to bail out Rhode Island?

Looks like another stroke of genius from Murphy and his crew of 'Loonies'.

Let's have more hearings on this ide (Loosely translated: more booze, more giant shrimp, and some good cigars.)



dave from Ashaway said:

This is like a kid with divorced parents. Mommy says no, so the kid asks dad, hoping for better results.




Leave a comment

Please be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published. Name and email are required; email address will not publish.




Type the characters you see in the picture above.