Projo 7 to 7 News BlogTaking the news pulse of Rhode Island and Southeastern Massachusetts, by Providence Journal and projo.com staff, from 7 to 7, every business day |
|
Get the 7 to 7 on your mobile at www.projo.com. Twitter: projo | RSS | Email alerts
« Newport man, 21, arrested in weekend stabbing |
Main
| Gianquitti trial: Defense's closing argument »
PROVIDENCE, R.I. -- In about six weeks, Louis Pagano will celebrate his 10th birthday. "And I use the term 'celebrate' very loosely, because I think you all know that for the rest of that boy's life, he'll regret the thought of his birthday," Assistant Attorney General William Ferland told the jury in closing arguments in the murder trial of Nicholas Gianquitti Tuesday afternoon. "The State of Rhode Island and the Pagano family are not looking for your sympathy," Ferland said. "I want you to consider the fact that this was Louis Pagano's birthday party, so (that) you can see the senselessness of James Pagano's death." Nicholas Gianquitti, 40, of 16 Daisy Court in Cranston, was charged with gunning down his next-door neighbor, a Cranston fire lieutenant, on May 18, 2008. The two had sparred over the manner in which Gianquitti spoke to Pagano's children and nephews after they hit Gianquitti's car with a stray tennis ball while playing baseball on the Cranston cul-de-sac. Gianquitti, who briefly served as a Providence police officer before retiring on disability, has said he shot Pagano because he feared for his life as Pagano came into his house. "Do not let this defendant minimize his conduct," Ferland told the jurors, after an impassioned description of the events that led to Gianquitti and Pagano's confrontation. "Folks, please, we've got to put it in context." "First of all," Ferland told the jury, Gianquitti was in his bedroom when Pagano came to his door. "Don't let him tell you otherwise," the assistant attorney general said. Establishing Gianquitti's location in the master bedroom "is important because that's where the gun is," Ferland said, suggesting Gianquitti went to the bedroom to get the gun when Pagano started banging on his door. Gianquitti's wife, Ferland said, initially told the police she didn't see her husband carrying a gun until her left the bedroom to answer the door, but left that detail out of her written statement to police and denied it when she testified Monday. "She's backed away from that because she understands the significance," Ferland said. Addresssing the self-defense argument, Ferland told the jury, a homeowner is not allowed to use deadly force unless he faces imminent danger of death or great bodily harm. Pagano, as a father, did "what any dad in (would do) when the neighbor swears at the kids," Ferland said, noting when Pagano went to Gianquitti's house he did not intend to kill Gianquitti. "Is he going to give him the 'what for' for swearing at his kids?" Of course," Ferland said. Pagano died from a single gunshot to the torso, according to autopsy results. Dr. Alexander Chirkov, the state's assistant medical examiner, who conducted the autopsy, testified last week that the bullet entered through Pagano's lower back and traveled at a 45-degree angle, tearing through Pagano's aorta, pancreas and liver. As for the second shot, Ferland said, Gianquitti chose to forget the shot because it was in his best interest. "He knew he hit (Pagano). He knew (Pagano) had a bullet in him," Ferland said. "You see, he can't remember that (the shot. If he remembers that, that demonstrates to you malice. His flimsy self-defense defense evaporates. "So, conveniently he has no recollection of" shooting the gun a second time, Ferland said. "That second shot is malice," he said. Malice is one of the elements required to secure a murder conviction. Gianquitti was indicted by a grand jury in August on charges of murder and discharging a firearm during the commission of a violent crime. He has been held at the Adult Correctional Institutions in Cranston since his arrest. Get the latest blog posts from the trial. Extra:Our continuing report on the shooting of James Pagano. CommentsLeave a commentPlease be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published. Name and email are required; email address will not publish. |
|
|
|
"Both men were wrong. One punch can kill just like one shot."
Report Abuse
That is correct, but with according to the jury in the other case in RI yesterday, you are allowed to take a free punch at someone.
Report Abuse